Featured Posts

Hostage to DoublethoughtHostage to Doublethought "It's too hard", he complains plaintively. "He, G-d, will understand. My son, he is a Rabbi. In Brooklyn. He is Lubavitch. (Here, he serenades me with the first few bars of...

Readmore

An Open Letter to Seminary Girls In a tradition dating back to the opening of the doors of the first seminary way back when in the fifties, the second week of Elul is host to an ingathering of exiles, so...

Readmore

Holiness in HaifaHoliness in Haifa Being a yeshiva student in Jerusalem is a wonderful experience. Aside from the learning, obviously, the people, places, and things to do never end. Indeed, I've fallen in...

Readmore

Goodbye, But Not For LongGoodbye, But Not For Long I and quite few other bochurim will be returning to Chutz La'aretz in just a few days. I can't wait for that flight. Not. I suppose I should be thankful though; Boruch...

Readmore

The Old Candy Man and The Candy StoreThe Old Candy Man and The Candy Store "Who can take tomorrow, dip it in a dream Separate the sorrow and collect up all the cream The Candy Man can, oh the Candy Man can The Candy Man can 'cause he mixes...

Readmore

The Case for Learning in Israel

Posted by Yeshiva Guy | Posted in Eretz Yisroel, Learning, Torah | Posted on 02-07-2009

0

Lately, as it has become the fashion to send to bochurim to Eretz Yisroel, it has become all the rage to bash Eretz Yisroel. They say: What’s the point? There’s no hashgacha there anyway! Better they should learn here…All this and more, I’ve heard, echoing throughout the minds of concerned parents across America. And indeed, they have a point. Its true, there is much less hashgacha here in Eretz Yisroel. There is, however, at the same time, much more hashgacha; albeit a different kind of hasgacha. The Hashgacha. And as frum yidden, we all believe in that higher hashgacha. I’m not referring to the Great Hashgacha here; I’m referring to Torah, and its unique brand of protection that it, and only it, can provide.

While it may be true that bochurim here have the time of their life, and that bochurim here have tons of fun, and that bochurim here…yada yada yada, its also true that bochurim here grow in ways they never could in America. The reasons for this are as many as they are few. That is, many reasons have been proffered, but I’d stick with the Gemara;
Aveerah D’Yisroel Machkim“.

I rest my case.

(Photo by turmsegler)


Post a comment