The Coffee Life
Bored and hunting some entertainment of the human interactive sort, I survey a juicy target surveying a sort of cup or thermos device with eager anticipation.
“Shalom Aleichem, R’ Yid. Is that a portable French Press?”, I ask, the badly disguised sense of wonder in my voice betraying me.
“It certainly is, my friend. I’m just about finished brewing, and as it happens, this makes half a cup extra. Would you like some?”, the middle aged guy with the graying temples and faded blue Toronto Maple Leafs cap and matching sweatshirt offers.
“I’d like nothing better”, I answer, sliding myself into the armchair next to him, and settling in comfortably. Meanwhile, he pulls out a package of mini “Shock” chocolate milks from his duffel. My luck holds, as a cursory inspection reveals that the milks bear a Badatz Eidah hashgacha; mochachinos, here we come. He carefully pours the aromatic chestnut brown liquid into two hot cups, and my mouth waters. Yup, this is gashmius.
It is a mini Bein Hazmanim, of sorts, and I’m up North at a small sports complex. It’s a mite chilly out, and I’m exhausted after a long day of traveling and exercise.
“L’Chaim“, I say, leaning back, sipping the piping hot java. I ask the friendly Canuck where he hails from, although the answer is patently obvious. “Haifa, by way of Toronto- you?”, he queries in reply. After telling him a little about myself, we begin to discuss Anglo life in Tel Aviv, and raising children there. His eldest, Amichai, is attending the local pseudo-Charedi yeshiva. Immensely proud of him, he calls him over. “Amichai, meet YG”. We schmooze for a bit- I ask him what masechta he’s learning, what he got for Chanukah, etc. The father isn’t proud for nothing. The child is an exceptionally intelligent, well adjusted, personable eighth grader if I ever saw one. Soon, he wanders off, leaving us to be mamshich our conversation.
Daddy continues by describing the progress his son has made in the Chareidi cheder. His son has taken to Gemara like a kibbutznik to the army, and is in love with it; on some days, he prefers learning to Xbox, PlayStation, or whatever video game console the family owns. Once in a while he even learns by himself. Daddy seems to revel in his son’s growth, and this is as it should be. No fan of learning vicariously himself, he begins every day at 5:30AM, and learns a full morning seder after Shacharis on alternating weekdays. The other days, various shiurim and chavrusahshafts take up the remainder of his free time. Indeed, a Dati Leuminik k’hilchoso. And although gratified by his son’s joy in learning, he now has a serious problem.
It seems that his son has reached the grade level where they must choose a yeshiva ketanah for next year- the Israeli equivalent of junior high school. And apparently, the yeshiva he is now in doesn’t offer a very advanced general studies curriculum at that grade level. The father, personally, might potentially be all right with a home study type of solution, but his wife…never. This, of course, means he must send him to a place that does offer more advanced studies. The only local place that has a decent English program? Bnei Akiva. So there it is. The age old question of academics vs. Torah. By the time he’s finished outlining his dilemma, I’m nodding my head fairly vigorously. Saying I am familiar with this is an understatement. At some point, many yeshiva bochurim deal with this problem- particularly those from less yeshivishe backgrounds, where the parents have a decided sway towards secular studies. More than one chaver of mine has had to deal with this, at varying levels of seriousness. At the far end of the spectrum, we have university; Boruch Hashem, so far, I haven’t had any friends encounter the college conundrum, but certainly as we move more towards the right on the scale, even yeshivishe chevra deal with this. But back to our charitable coffee nadvan…
Wrapping up, he looks at me with a sort of sheepish face. He knows what I think about all this. Thank G-d. Because I certainly don’t want to get involved in his shalom bayis. All I need to do is acknowledge his rueful mien with a subtle confirming glance- which I attempt- and we should be copacetic.
We aren’t. He doesn’t let it go.
“So, nu, what do you think?”, he pushes. “Is it k’dai to send him to the Bnei Akiva school? He’s excelling in Gemara, and I know that it won’t be nearly the same there.” Now, I really am at a loss. He knows what I think. I think he’s an idiot for sending his kid into the abyss because of his spiritual Mata Hari. I think that if, after millenia of life in societies where we didn’t have the option or wherewithal b’chlall to send our offspring to cheder, and you now have both, you’ve got to be meshugah to even contemplate anything else.
“I think it’s none of my business, but you’re pushing me. You’re going to have to think this through yourself, but to put it one way: What you want and what is right happen to coincide. In the end, it boils down to this: Do you want your kid to be a beanie wearing barista, or a bochur swilling the beans he’s serving”?
So saying, I finish off the remaining dregs of coffee, and stand up and look down at him.
“Whatever happens, achi, remember this. It’s all about one thing. Make sure all decisions reflect this one thing, and you’ll be fine…
L’Chaim“.
